Have you ever stopped to think about how often you are consulted as you go about your everyday life? Much of this consultation happens without us even realising that we are being consulted! For example, when we go into a restaurant the wait staff will hand us a menu and then consult us as to what we would like to eat. If we join a gym the staff will consult with us about which of the services they offer, would be most helpful to us. Medical specialists will offer us several treatment options and then consult with us as to which one we think will be best for us. I’m sure you can think of many other examples as well.
The thing that all these examples have in common is that the consultation revolves around the professional knowledge of the person offering the service. For example, when we walk into a restaurant the wait staff don’t just ask us what we would like to eat. They offer us a menu, designed by a chef, made up of food combinations informed by professional knowledge, cost and the availability of ingredients. We are very familiar with being consulted about a limited number of choices, informed by others with more professional knowledge than us.
When it comes to setting the strategic direction for a business or an organisation such as a school, it is critical to get the consultation process right. My advice is to ignore any advice that suggests you should consult with employees and communities ahead of setting strategic goals. Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not for one minute suggesting that stakeholder voice is not important, it is. But, if you consult too early when setting strategic goals you end up inviting novices to tell you, the professional what to do.
When we put novices in the position of telling professionals what to do one of two things happens. The first thing is absolutely nothing. Zip. Zilch. A deafening silence on the other end of your community survey. When you ask people questions to which they do not know have the answer, it should be unsurprising that they simply don’t respond.
The second thing that can happen is that you give a soapbox to the vocal minorities. The biggest danger to this is that their advice is often in conflict with your professional values and beliefs. In my experience, giving voice to novice minorities never ends well!
The process that invites novices to tell professionals what to do looks like this:

What I believe we are better to do, is to shift consultation from the start of the process to the middle to look something like this:

Strategy should be drafted by professionals. They are the ones with the most knowledge, experience and training. Part of this professional knowledge should be an understanding of the needs of the people they serve.
The strategy should then be socialised amongst the stakeholders for their feedback. This should be done in a way that makes it clear that we are looking for input from them about what we might have missed or advice about how we could make the strategy even better. It is important that at this stage of the process, we listen intently and resist any temptation to say “Yes, but…”
The final stage is to look at the feedback that has come from your consultation and use it to update and in many cases improve your original strategy. The final stage is to create your annual plan.
From theory to reality
I was working with a school the other week that decided they wanted to flip the advice they’d been given about the strategic planning process. They already had strategic goals which met the requirements of the updated Education and Training Act, so they weren’t keen to start again. But they also wanted to consult with their community to ensure their strategic goals were fit for purpose and to meet the requirements of the Act.
To add to the complexity the majority of the school’s families were not native English speakers. We decided the best way to consult was by producing a video that used photos to illustrate each strategic goal, along with a commentary given by the principal that included translated captions. We brainstormed the key ideas for each strategic goal. We then asked ChatGPT to produce a video script for non-native speakers of English. The script we got back was amazing. ChatGPT even described what the photos should illustrate and where in the video to put them!
Consultation is an important part of the strategic planning process. Equally important though, is to ensure that consultation improves your strategy without giving you more challenges to solve.
Til next time
Carolyn
P.S. If my thinking about consultation resonates with you, then you’ll love my new book. It is the first in The Leader’s Suitcase Trilogy, a series of books and Masterclasses that provide leaders with the essential equipment for their journey.